Commercial Due Diligence
Commercial due diligence tests the 1 document no seller will warrant: the forecast. Much of the evidence sits outside the company.
What Commercial Due Diligence Tests
Sometimes called market due diligence, the review answers 4 questions. Each one is an assumption in the model.
Is the market as big as claimed?
Addressable market, growth drivers, reachable share. A bottom-up count beats a borrowed headline number.
Matters most to: the investment committee
Why does it win.
Win/loss records, pricing against rivals, switching costs. 1 feature or 1 relationship is a thin position.
Matters most to: the buyer pricing the multiple
Will customers stay and pay more.
Retention by cohort, concentration, contract terms. Then the reference call.
Matters most to: the lender sizing the debt
Is the plan achievable.
Pipeline conversion, sales capacity, price rises already assumed. Each line of the forecast is tested alone.
Matters most to: the management team that has to deliver it
Financial review confirms what was earned. This review decides whether it will be earned again.
Commercial Due Diligence Document Checklist
Management teams: assemble this before launch. Buyers: start the request list here.
Business plan and forecast
3 to 5 years, every entity
- ✓ Management business plan with assumptions by revenue line
- ✓ Budget against actual for the last 3 years
- ✓ Forecast bridge from the current year to the plan year
- ✓ Board strategy papers and the last strategic review
- ✓ Definitions and history for every reported KPI
Market size and growth
Latest available
- ✓ Market sizing model, total and served (TAM and SAM), with its sources
- ✓ Third-party market reports bought or commissioned
- ✓ Segment definitions and the segments actually served
- ✓ Growth drivers and pending regulatory change
- ✓ Substitutes and adjacent markets
Competitive position
3 years
- ✓ Competitor list by segment
- ✓ Win and loss analysis with stated reasons
- ✓ Market share estimates and how they were built
- ✓ Competitor pricing intelligence
- ✓ New entrants and recent competitor transactions
Customer base
3 to 5 years
- ✓ Revenue by customer by year
- ✓ Top customer contracts with term and renewal date
- ✓ Concentration analysis for the top 10 and top 20
- ✓ Segmentation by size, sector and geography
- ✓ New customers by year and by channel
- ✓ Recurring revenue as a share of the total
Retention and churn
By cohort, 3 years minimum
- ✓ Gross and net revenue retention by cohort
- ✓ Lost customer list with the reason for each
- ✓ Renewal schedule for the next 24 months
- ✓ Satisfaction or NPS survey results with the raw responses
- ✓ Complaint and escalation logs
Pricing and margin
3 years
- ✓ Price lists and the discount policy
- ✓ Realized price by product and by customer
- ✓ Price increase history and customer response
- ✓ Discounts approved outside policy
- ✓ Gross margin by product, customer and channel
- ✓ Unit economics: acquisition cost against customer lifetime value
Sales pipeline
Current plus 8 quarters
- ✓ Pipeline by stage with the age of each deal
- ✓ Historic conversion rate by stage
- ✓ Sales cycle length by segment
- ✓ Forecast accuracy by quarter
- ✓ Lost deal log with the winning competitor
- ✓ Order backlog and how fast it converts to revenue
Sales and marketing engine
Current structure plus 3 years
- ✓ Sales headcount, tenure and quota attainment
- ✓ Ramp time for new sales hires
- ✓ Marketing spend and acquisition cost by channel
- ✓ Commission plans and recent changes
- ✓ Lead sources and their share of new business
Channels and partners
All in force
- ✓ Distributor and reseller agreements
- ✓ Revenue and margin by channel
- ✓ Partner concentration
- ✓ Exclusivity and territory restrictions
Products and roadmap
Current plus 3 years
- ✓ Revenue by product and lifecycle stage
- ✓ Roadmap with funding and delivery dates
- ✓ Launch history against the original plan
- ✓ Customer feature requests and their status
Expansion and new markets
Where the plan depends on it
- ✓ Business case for each new market or segment
- ✓ Results of earlier expansions against their case
- ✓ Local competitors and route to market
- ✓ Investment required before the 1st revenue
Customer and market access
Agreed before launch, not found in a folder
- ✓ Customers the seller will allow a buyer to contact
- ✓ Terms and timing for reference calls
- ✓ Earlier customer surveys that can be shared
- ✓ Rules for contacting former employees and industry experts
- ✓ Clean team terms where the buyer is a competitor
AI and demand shift
Where AI changes how customers buy
- ✓ Exposure of each product to substitution by AI tools
- ✓ Share of leads from search, and how it has moved
- ✓ AI features on the roadmap and customer uptake so far
- ✓ Pricing tied to user seats where customers are cutting seats
- ✓ Competitor AI launches and their effect on win rate
The financial workstream verifies historic revenue. Legal review covers contract terms and change of control.
Commercial Due Diligence Runs on Customer Data
Revenue by customer, cohorts, pipeline, pricing. Indexed by question, not by department.
The Forecast and the Evidence Behind It
A forecast is 6 assumptions multiplied together. Test each against a different source. 4 of the 6 need evidence from outside the company.
If you built the model, this is the order in which you take it apart.
3 ways a forecast fails review
None of them show in the historical accounts.
Growth that was bought.
Revenue rose on discounts or one-off contracts. The trend does not repeat at list price.
Retention carried by 1 cohort.
The blended figure looks stable. The newest customers are leaving faster than the oldest.
A plan that needs everything to go right.
Each assumption is defensible alone. Together they describe a year the company has never had.
A seller who shows the cohort data controls the story. One who shows only the blended number gets the buyer's version.
Red Flags in Commercial Due Diligence
10 findings that move a multiple. Management teams should read this list before the buyer's advisers do.
Sellers: explain the top 3 in the plan itself. Buyers: test them on the 1st customer call.
The largest customer renews within 12 months
You are buying a negotiation, not a contract.
Net retention held up by price rises
Volume is falling. The invoice is hiding it.
Market size taken from a single analyst report
A borrowed number, sized for somebody else's product.
Reference customers chosen only by the seller
Happy customers are a sample, not evidence.
Win rate falling against 1 named competitor
Something changed, and the plan assumes it did not.
Late-stage deals that have stopped moving
A deal that does not move is not pipeline.
Heavy discounting at every quarter end
Revenue pulled forward at the next quarter's expense.
A budget missed 3 years running
That is a track record, and it belongs in the model.
Growth that depends on an unlaunched product
The plan counts revenue nobody has agreed to pay.
Lost customers nobody will let you call
The reasons are known. They are just not on the list.
From Commercial Due Diligence to Deal Terms
Commercial findings cannot be indemnified. They change what the buyer pays, or how the payment is structured.
The report has 2 readers. The investment committee reads the base case. The lender reads the downside.
The Customer List Is the Most Sensitive File in the Deal
On a strategic bid, the reader is a competitor. Keep pricing and customer names to a clean team.
Commercial Due Diligence by Deal Type
The questions stay the same. Who commissions the work, and who relies on it, changes.
On a buy-side process
3 to 6 weeks, run by a strategy adviser alongside financial review. Customer calls need the seller's consent. Settle access in the letter of intent, not after it.
On a sell-side process
A vendor commercial report or commercial fact book goes to every bidder. It sets the story before bidders write their own. The winner tops it up.
On a financing or fundraise
Same analysis, different question. Lenders and growth investors want the floor under revenue, not the upside.
Strategy consultancies and specialist boutiques do this work. Expert interviews and customer surveys are their tools. Sponsors repeat it on every platform deal, scaled down for bolt-ons.
Frequently Asked Questions
The questions heads of tax and deal teams actually ask, in the order the process forces them.
An independent review of a target’s market, competitors, customers, and business plan before a transaction. Commercial due diligence tests whether future revenue is as likely as management claims.
Financial due diligence verifies historic earnings from the company's own records. Commercial due diligence assesses future revenue using customers, competitors, and market data. Most deals run both in parallel.
Both, in different fields. In M&A, CDD is commercial due diligence. In banking and compliance, the same letters stand for customer due diligence, the identity checks required under anti-money-laundering rules.
3 to 6 weeks on most mid-market deals. A red-flag review can be done in 1 to 2 weeks before an offer. Scheduling customer calls usually sets the pace.
Strategy consultancies or specialist commercial advisers, appointed by the buyer or its lender. Corporate buyers sometimes do it in-house, though credit committees and boards tend to want an outside view.
Usually, but late and on conditions. Sellers limit calls to named accounts, often only once exclusivity is granted. Where calls are refused, advisers fall back on surveys and former customers.
Market size and growth, competitive position, customer analysis, a view on the business plan, and a revised forecast. The revised forecast feeds into the valuation model.
A commercial report the seller commissions before launch and shares with bidders. It speeds up early rounds, though most buyers still commission a shorter review.
Rarely. Sellers do not warrant forecasts, and warranty insurers exclude forward-looking statements. That leaves price and structure as the only places a commercial finding can go.
Commercial Due Diligence Rewards the Seller Who Shows the Cohorts
Customer data, pipeline, and pricing in 1 indexed place. Sensitive files held back until the right stage.